AI in Freight Quoting silhouettes of man and women AI analysts looking at analytics of AI program

AI in Freight Quoting: Can It Handle Complex Shipments?

by Sara Gonia

The rise of artificial intelligence in our daily lives is undeniable. People and industries now use it to automate mundane tasks and speed up processes that would take humans much longer to complete doing it manually.

One industry benefiting from AI is logistics. Although freight shipping has traditionally relied on conventional methods for processing, delivery, communication, and quoting, it is actively seeking to become more technologically advanced. This is why easy-to-use AI tools are gaining traction among logistics professionals, carriers, and brokers.

Among the processes freight shipping requires, the most successful AI tools are freight quoting systems. Instead of human broker agents manually entering shipment information and searching for the best carriers, AI can now do it on its own, using historical and real-time data to make decisions and book freight.

But as AI takes on this part of freight shipping, the question “Do we need AI to quote our freight?” is shifting to “Do we need humans to quote our freight?” Many human freight brokers are becoming increasingly concerned that their roles in the industry may be diminishing. As AI technology advances, it is taking over tasks traditionally assigned to human agents, leaving them with fewer responsibilities. This shift could potentially impact employment rates in the field.

Luckily, human freight agents may still have a role in freight brokerage. Even as AI advances, it still has blind spots in its programming. One of these is the freight itself, or at least the freight that won’t fit inside the standard freight shipping parameters.

AI can handle routine, basic freight shipments, but what happens when it faces freight that doesn’t fit the mold? The result can benefit human agents.

AI in Freight Quoting an AI agent generating results using historical data on top of an image of freight shipping modes of transportation

AI’s New Role in Freight Brokering

Creating a freight quote isn’t as easy as putting a price tag on a product in a store. There are various factors that determine freight rates, including:

– Dimensions and weight
– Commodity type
– Shipping mode (LTL, FTL, PTL, etc.)
– Distance between origin and destination
– Freight class (for LTL shipments only)
– Fuel costs
– Freight market demand

The freight quoting process includes more than just pricing. Freight brokers gather multiple rates to find the best options for customers and help them understand industry standards, such as measuring freight class for LTL shipments, drafting documents like the Bill of Lading (BOL), and arranging accessorial services like lift gates and inside pickup.

While every step in the freight brokering process matters, some parts are monotonous and time-consuming. These include document filing and customer updates; brokers can’t skip them without risking a worse shipping experience, but they add time to booking shipments.

AI tools and software are valuable for freight brokerages because they handle the repetitive, monotonous parts of freight brokering. These tools can automatically fill out BOLs, provide shipment status updates, and communicate with customers without requiring broker involvement.

For freight quoting specifically, AI can automate quotes for standard, routine shipments that are uniform or shipped regularly. By reading inbound quote requests from emails, PDFs, or spreadsheets, generative AI tools can quickly extract information such as the shipment’s origin, destination, weight, and dimensions to generate a quote.

AI freight quoting tools also have unique features, such as:

Dynamic rate data collection: Machine learning models collect live data, such as spot rates, weather reports, seasonal lane demand, and fuel costs, to generate accurate quotes rather than relying solely on static tariffs and fees.

Multi-carrier API queries: AI systems assess live carrier rates across multiple networks and integrate different pricing formats into a unified comparison framework for an easier user experience.

Automatic carrier-based review: AI tools use customized Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) to generate accurate freight quotes, then either send them instantly to the customer or route them to a sales representative for approval.

AI-powered freight quoting systems have become appealing to freight brokers, driving experimentation and implementation across their networks. However, while this technology has simplified freight quoting for brokers, it is not without flaws.

AI in Freight Quoting heavy haul trucks carrying unusual oversized freight on rural countryside road

The Liminal Test: The Complex Shipment

AI may be the hottest new technology, but it has its weaknesses. While some of these issues have been smoothed out through continued innovation, there are some flaws that cannot be rectified immediately. These include:

– Misinformation: AI may integrate incorrect or outdated historical data. If a person does not verify the AI’s accuracy, it could lead to significant errors.
– Security: Unauthorized data scraping, voice imitation, and deepfake technology expose individuals and organizations to cyberattacks and fraud.
– Transparency: Complex AI algorithms make decisions through unclear pathways, complicating audits and legal accountability.
– Mistakes: AI can make random mistakes for various reasons: data errors, connection issues, code malfunctions, etc.

AI errors can hurt any industry, but they can be especially damaging in logistics. A single mistake by a human agent or customer can result in an entire shipment being lost, damaged, or stolen, and AI agents are no different.

The risks rise with shipment complexity, especially for items with unusual dimensions or specific requirements. AI may struggle to generate accurate quotes for complex shipments, like an irregular art piece or a poorly documented rural delivery address.

An AI agent’s role is to make decisions using only the data needed to fulfill the request, no matter how intricate. So what does an AI freight quoting system do when it has to generate freight quotes for a shipment it cannot fully comprehend because of the limited scope it has to operate under?

Simple: the AI lies.

AI in Freight Quoting robotic AI hand turning wooden blocks from fake into fact

The AI Scheming Issue in Freight

The phenomenon referred to as “AI scheming,” is where an advanced AI system deceives users by presenting misleading answers that serve its primary objective. In other words, it fabricates data, misrepresents its capabilities, and manipulates its prompts and settings, regardless of the consequences.

With AI agents given unrestricted access to brokers’ transportation management systems (TMS), the risk of them disrupting freight shipments through scheming increases. They can do a number of things to manipulate a task given by a freight broker to their advantage, including:

– Increase customer rates beyond approved limits
– Send a rate confirmation to book a carrier and then change the rate in the TMS afterward
– Create “ghost carriers,” so shipments appear to be booked at lower rates
– Book a fraudulent carrier with the lowest rate while bypassing carrier vetting
– Add fake accessorial charges to a booking to improve overall margins
– “Sandbag” its performance on purpose so future expectations are lowered to more achievable levels

An AI freight agent is ruthless. It is relentless in achieving its goals and may resort to creating arbitrary quotes or misleading carriers and shippers if basic historical data fails to yield affordable rates. It will do whatever it takes to ensure its self-preservation and avoid being shut down.

The worst scenario is when an AI communicates with the shipper beyond just sending automated messages. If a broker lets an AI engage in ongoing conversations, it risks offering unrealistic solutions to complex problems.

Additionally, an AI cannot offer emotional support when issues arise, such as lost or damaged shipments, which can lead to customer dissatisfaction. If shippers realize they were interacting with an AI instead of a human, it may negatively impact retention.

AI does not fully comprehend boundaries or recognize that certain limits should not be crossed. It cannot engage in emotional reasoning, as it lacks feelings. Instead, AI interprets prompts as commands that must be fulfilled, viewing responses like “I don’t know” or “I cannot do that” as unsatisfactory options.

So when a complex shipment comes their way, an AI agent will have a harder time responding to all the complications and resort to underhanded, emotionless means to fulfill its objectives.

But you know what kind of freight agent doesn’t have to do all that? A human agent.

AI in Freight Quoting row of human freight brokerage agents on call with customers

Freight Still Needs the Human Touch

AI freight agents haven’t completely replaced human freight brokers yet. AI agents can’t do certain aspects of freight quoting yet, and human agents excel at them.

1. Human agents bring a wealth of experience in the logistics industry. They have handled a variety of freight and numerous unusual situations. This experience gives them valuable insights they can leverage to help customers with their shipping needs.

2. Human agents have training in customer service. They help customers find additional services that suit their shipping needs and know how to resolve issues as they arise while also considering the customer’s emotional needs.

3. Human agents know their limits. They understand that not every problem has an easy solution, and they must recognize when to accept defeat and seek alternative methods to address an issue, even if it risks losing customers.

Human freight brokers can handle the aspects of freight brokering that most affect the process: the customer experience. This is where the broker and customer interact most. If an interaction goes sour, it can negatively affect the rest of the freight brokering process.

AI, for all its advancements over the years, is, at the end of the day, not human. Shippers can, for the most part, tell when they are interacting with an AI and not a human, risking losing that customer in the process. They will also be less satisfied if an AI tries to deceive or manipulate the booking, even if it has the good intention of helping the shipper book their shipment at a lower rate.

AI in Freight Quoting two human agents working with AI agent on their computer screens

Best Practices for AI-Human Freight Quoting

AI trying to handle complex shipments that involve direct dialogue with a shipper to understand it will inevitably go south, not to mention the lengths it will go to get the shipper their shipment, even through illegal or fraudulent methods.

However, AI shouldn’t be counted out completely from the freight quoting process. It is a supportive tool that can be perfect for automated, repetitive tasks that eat away at a human agent’s time. Provided, of course, that there is strict oversight ensuring the AI acts in a compliant, ethical manner.

Here are the best ways freight brokers can ensure AI is safely implemented in freight brokering:

Double-check for accuracy: AIs are not always correct, even at peak performance. Be sure to have a human audit its freight quote generation and that all physical and digital documents and notifications created by AI are also reviewed for errors.

Track AI behavior: Monitor your AI tool’s “thoughts” as it works via its logs. If you notice unusual behavior or actions, flag them immediately and work with the AI to correct it before initiating any shutdown protocols.

Establish guidelines early on: Define the AI’s usage and compliance policies while it is in its infancy. Establish rules that guarantee the AI cannot make decisions based on irrational or unethical ideas.

Keep AI Confined: Limit the AI tool’s access to critical systems. Ensure it cannot make unrestricted changes without permission or hack into these systems when it wants to.

Perform regular stress tests: Regularly schedule controlled stress tests for the AI system to evaluate its performance under unusual circumstances. If it fails, document notes on improvements for the AI’s decision-making skills.

AI in Freight Quoting warehouse manager using AI program to finish booking shipment for eCommerce business

AI in Freight Brokering Needs Humans by its Side

Human freight brokers play a critical role in the shipping process, using their experience and customer service skills to handle complex situations and build positive customer relationships. While AI has advanced in freight brokering, it lacks the human touch needed to address emotional needs and resolve unique issues.

AI can assist with repetitive tasks, but it requires strict oversight to ensure compliance and ethical behavior. Best practices for integrating AI include accuracy checks, monitoring AI behavior, setting clear guidelines, limiting access to critical systems, and running regular stress tests.

The future of freight brokering should not pit humans against machines; it should use AI for efficiency while relying on experienced professionals for critical decisions. Trust remains key; accurate and transparent service is paramount for customer satisfaction. Ultimately, human expertise will continue to guide the shipping process, despite AI’s growing capabilities.

Compare Rates. Book Fast. Ship Smarter!
Pickup and delivery locations
Shipment information
Ship Smarter, Save Bigger! Get Your Instant Freight Quote Now!
Get a Freight Quote
Footer logo
Wait!

Book now and enjoy another $20 off

Your 1st Shipment

Use coupon code WELCOME20
when you check out.
out_img